“Should I apply Early Decision?”
The logic seems simple: the admit rate is usually higher, decisions are returned sooner, and the anxiety ends. But Early Decision (ED) is not a magic bullet, because higher odds aren’t the same as guaranteed fit. ED truncates strategy, timing, and financial flexibility. In return, you might be rewarded with a guaranteed seat. Whether ED is right for your student depends on their academic preparation, maturity, and the depth of their college search.
What Early Decision is
Early Decision is a binding agreement between your student and the college: If accepted, they must attend. Colleges offer it because it fills a part of their class early. This provides the school insight into the makeup of the incoming cohort. From the college’s perspective, ED mitigates risks along the parameters of number of students in a class (can we fill enough seats to maintain the community?), the quality of those students (will they help our academic profile?), and how much financial aid they need (how many can pay?). Colleges want to have a good year, too.
From the student’s perspective, Early Decision signals commitment and, in most cases, improves chances of admission at their first-choice school. But how much those chances increase depends on the colleges goals and the makeup of the ED applicant pool that year.
“If you have a particular “hook” in a year a school is looking for one— geographic and socioeconomic diversity, a major in demand, legacy or recruited athlete status — your ED chances could improve markedly.”
In short, Early Decision charges a premium for a measure of certainty. What that premium costs, and how much certainty you receive, will change depending on the college’s selectivity and what type of early plan they’re selling.
How Early Decision is different than Early Action & Restrictive Early Action
It’s important to be clear that not all early plans are the same. Some require a commitment to attend, while others don’t.
- Early Action (EA): You apply and receive a decision early (typically before the new year), but aren’t bound to attend if admitted. Under this agreement, you can apply EA to other schools.
- Restrictive Early Action (REA): Also known as Single Choice Early Action (SCEA), REA is a non-binding application. You apply early to one private school, and are restricted from applying to others. However, you can usually still apply early to public universities.
- Early Decision (ED): You apply early knowing that, if admitted, you are obligated to attend. You are not allowed to apply ED to another school. Decisions are returned before the new year.
- Early Decision II (ED II): A second binding round at some colleges, usually with a January deadline, for students who missed the first window and still wish to apply ED.
Why so many early options? It wasn’t long ago that colleges only offered regular and early decision programs. But as the Baby Boomer generation completed their degrees, decreasing numbers of college-aged students prompted schools to adapt new ways to maintain enrollments. For today’s colleges, additional Early Action and Early Decision rounds provide more opportunities to develop relationships with applicants and recruit them before the competition does — in addition to providing greater access for students with a desire to attend.
(Aside: Is there a collective action problem/social dilemma if schools continue to increase the early admission rounds; increases confusion for a public and may dissuade application)
Know, then, that each early option is offered for a reason and requires its own calculus. Students must think carefully about their psychological and academic readiness, as well as any financial considerations. In general, Early Decision I and II are best for students confident in their academic profiles, have their applications in order, and are assured that their family can bear the financial costs involved of attending. In deciding on ED applications, families must balance the potential boost in admission chances against the ability to compare possible financial aid awards across multiple institutions.
In short, the more binding the commitment, the more certain you need to be. In our experience, successful ED outcomes are the result of months of preparation, which include an intelligent college search process and time spent iterating well-written essays.
The risks of Early Decision: finances and fit
Applying early just because admission rates are usually higher, is a recipe for discontent. It’s worth reiterating that because ED is binding, you are surrendering the choice to compare financial aid offers that you could receive by submitting in the regular decision round. For families who need to weigh need-based aid and merit awards, this is a major limitation. Even at colleges that promise to meet “full demonstrated need,” aid packages vary—and don’t always meet actual need.
There is the risk that ED’s compressed timeline causes students to give short shrift to college research and visits, miss opportunities for additional testing, and rush essays. Moreover, academic growth in the senior fall can strengthen a Regular Decision application. There’s also the risk of applying early cavalierly. With early application comes the emotional risk that, if rejected or deferred, students may experience deflation. Left unaddressed, this can lead to lackluster effort in preparing regular decision applications, and even affect senior year performance. Again, better admission odds are not a good reason to rush the process and jeopardize good fit.
Regardless of ED’s risks, it’s advisable to take advantage of the net price calculators offered on colleges’ websites. These calculators develop estimates of what your cost to attend a particular school would be. Since each college commits different amounts of money for financial aid, and has different policies on awarding that aid, each calculator is based on differing variables, such as family and business income, as well as home equity and savings. For example, colleges that offer merit awards have calculators requiring GPA and test scores. Remember, any calculator’s estimate is not an aid award. You’ll only know what your award will be by meeting deadlines and completing all required paperwork.
The reward side: confidence and commitment
When a student is confident that a school is the right place, and parents have done their homework about affordability, taking a shot at Early Decision is a good option. A college is more likely to love students who love them back, and value students who know why they belong there. In addition to helping mitigate enrollment risks, colleges tend to believe prepared ED admits are more likely to be retained over four years, sustaining vibrancy within the community. When students commit to their school, they’re more likely to stick it out to graduation when things get tough.
Working hard to apply early can also have the benefit of aiding regular decision submissions if needed. With the right emotional support, a rejection or deferral can motivate students to refine their materials further and double down on academic efforts. In particular, between early and regular decision, students’ essays often mature in terms of coherency and impact given that much of the heavy lifting has already been done.
With everything in place — preparations have been thorough and expectations managed — Early Decision’s greatest reward is that students will get a closer look.
At top schools, ED’s advantage for applicants is usually marginal, which still can make the difference in what is a hyper competitive process. These schools know that they will continue to receive highly qualified applicants in the regular decision round, and so don’t experience as much pressure passing on candidates. But quality institutions that aren’t household names don’t have that luxury. Outside the top 50, the difference between ED and RD admit rate can be substantial. For those schools, the sole question in Early Decision is: Can the student do the work?
For parents: Keep your eye on the ball
—Starting at least their junior year, stay on top of your student’s college search and application process. Give your student the space to determine if a school is right for them. But don’t abdicate your role in the process. If the fit is there and your student has done the work, ED can be a boon.
—Since you are signaling commitment, colleges can be less generous awarding aid in ED rounds, compared to what you could receive if your student is selected in the regular decision pool. Run the net price calculator the summer before their senior year, and talk to the financial aid office to clarify policies. Your student’s admission chances will not be threatened by your questions.
—Remember that even though chances of admission may be greater early, the applicant pool also tends to include more legacy candidates and recruited athletes. Therefore, competition can be stiff. If your student is rejected or deferred in an early round, keep encouraging their effort. Remind them that there are lots of great options still available, and that the application process is ongoing.
For students: Keep coming back to why you’re applying
—If you genuinely know where you belong, apply early. But if the choice feels forced in any way, then pause. Peer pressure is not a reason to commit to a school. What matters most is that your application efforts are aligned with your unique voice.
—Use the summer before your senior year to make headway on your college research and application essays. Continue to ask the question, “What do I want out of my college experience?” Clarify who you are and what kind of learning environment will support you best.
—Early Decision is not a be-all, end-all. A well-thought through Regular Decision list produces better results than an ED application made in haste.
Bottom line
Early Decision can be a powerful advantage in the right context. It’s a commitment, not a shortcut to success; colleges wouldn’t offer ED if it weren’t in their interests, too. Only after you’ve put in the work will you know whether applying early is right for you.
Schedule a call today
At Ecstawrite, we discuss your unique case, taking into consideration academic maturity and financial aid to determine if applying ED to a particular school is warranted. Helping families navigate the early-application landscape with strategy and calm, we are committed to availing all relevant options for students’ success.
Leave a Reply